Pages

Monday, 12 March 2012

'sometimes you have to stray into black or grey illegal areas'

December 2010 - Andy Coulson testifying at at the Tommy Sheridan perjury trial:
"I don't accept there was a culture of phone hacking at the News of the World. All I can tell you is that, as far as my reporters are concerned, the instructions were very clear: they were to work within the law and within the PCC code. It's in their handbooks." [2]

Ray Suarez of PBS News hour, in an interview with Sarah Ellison and Richard Adams, posed the question as to whether News of the World would ride out the hacking scandal when it had just featured celebrities and the royal family. The implication was that at this point, nobody was really surprised about the behaviour of the journalists - a career the Duke of Wellington decreed was reserved for the 'scum of the earth'. Sarah Ellison, author of 'War at the Wall Street Journal' suggested that July 2011's revelation of the hacking of a kidnapped teenager (who ended up dead) is what truly cemented News Internationals fate. This scandal had gone from trivial to a "much more dangerous and damning practice". [4]

So the question is, at what point does an invasion of privacy become more than the well acknowledged trait of the journalism trade. Article 8 of the Human Rights Act 1998 states that 'everyone has the right to respect for his private and family life, his home and his correspondence' [1].
Therefore surely everybody, be that those in the public eye or not, should have the right to privacy. So why did it take the media so long to damn what was quite clearly an illegal action. Paul McMullan, former News of the World deputy features editor said during the Leveson inquiry that as a journalist, or at least as a News of the World journalist, 'sometimes you have to stray into black or grey illegal areas'. He even went so far as to justify actions, saying "I don't think anyone realised that anyone was committing a crime".[3] The phone hacking scandal, be that before or after the more 'damning' of the revelations, was quite clearly a breach of the human rights act - however distorted your view of the law.

But why is this acceptable? How? The law may have grey areas, but this is a black and white section.

Privacy + Breach = Illegal

Is the media allowing this? Today's constant desire to be informed as to every detail of a strangers life is bizarre - at least to me it is. But has this inane part of our culture allowed the media to delve into peoples private lives? Time and time again we see celebrities being 'papped'. The knicker shots that see stars grace page 3 of the tabloids - is that simply part and parcel of being in the public eye? Should it be?

The point I'm trying to make here is as to whether we have allowed the media to reach this complicated and twisted climax. Each small victory of the media over privacy has surely allowed for a view that the law over privacy is objective.

Is social media doing anything more than allowing a continuation of this? Access to what years ago would have been private information is now a common and unremarkable practice.
Does it go deeper than that; is social media simply serving the true nature of humanity - voyeurism? And if so, can any of it be counted as wrong, never mind illegal, if it's simply serving an innate human need?

Katy x

References

[1] Book.
Banks D/Hanna M. McNae's essential law for journalists. Oxford University Press 2009

[2] Article.
Guardian. July 6th, 2011.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2011/jul/06/murdoch-executive-phone-hacking-denials

[3] Article.
Guardian. November 29th, 2011.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2011/nov/29/rebekah-brooks-andy-coulson-leveson-inquiry

[4] Video Interview
Suarez R. PBS Newshour. Original Air date July 8th, 2011.
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/media/july-dec11/notw2_07-08.html

No comments:

Post a Comment